new stack and improved skills.

[krisnye]

• the ecs skill has been simplified to direct the AI to use the node_modules/@adobe/data/AGENTS.md file. This allows ai improvements to be published from adobe/data itself, keeping improvements more cohesive. This pattern has been recommended for using all published packages that contain AGENTS.md files.
• adding aidd-stack skill to advise on tech stacks based upon requirements. The recommendations can be expanded.
• aidd-structure skill improved
• new aidd-ts-projects skill to teach how to properly use simple tsconfig files with project references to constrain dependencies.

[orionnye]

Possible redundancy with stack.mdc in rules, line 29-39 https://github.com/paralleldrive/aidd/blob/main/ai/rules/stack.mdc

`# Redux

Avoid Redux Toolkit. Use frameworks/redux/autodux and redux connect instead.

1. Build the Autodux dux object and save it as "${slice name}-dux.sudo"
2. Transpile to JavaScript and save it as "${slice name}-dux.js"

Constraints {
ALWAYS use tdd as defined in tdd.mdc when implementing source code changes.
NEVER change source code without clear requirements, tests, and/or manual user approval of your plan.
}`

[krisnye]

Yes. Eric pointed out we have to remove that and merge any missing logic needed into this.

[ericelliott]

@cursoragent please /review

Make sure there's a reference in AGENTS.md to ref to stack.
Stack should should be in aidd-custom/skills/stack/SKILL.md and fall back to ai/skills/stack/SKILL.md

[cursor]

Code Review Findings

🔴 Critical Issues

1. Missing AGENTS.md Reference

The AGENTS.md file lacks a reference to the stack skill. Based on the pattern in the file, there should be an entry like:

## Task Index

fix bug => /aidd-fix
choose stack => /stack

Location: /workspace/AGENTS.md

2. Incorrect Skill Naming and Location

The stack skill is currently at:

• ai/skills/aidd-stack/SKILL.md ❌

But according to your requirements, it should be:

• aidd-custom/skills/stack/SKILL.md (project-specific, primary)
• ai/skills/stack/SKILL.md (framework default, fallback)

The naming convention should be stack, not aidd-stack, when it's meant to be a customizable/overridable skill.

3. Redundancy with Existing Rules

As @orionnye noted in the PR comments, there's significant redundancy between:

# Redux

Avoid Redux Toolkit. Use frameworks/redux/autodux and redux connect instead.

1. Build the Autodux dux object and save it as "${slice name}-dux.sudo"
2. Transpile to JavaScript and save it as "${slice name}-dux.js"

Constraints {
  ALWAYS use tdd as defined in tdd.mdc when implementing source code changes.
  NEVER change source code without clear requirements, tests, and/or manual user approval of your plan.
}

And:

### Redux

Avoid Redux Toolkit. Use frameworks/redux/autodux and redux connect instead.

1. Build the Autodux dux object and save it as "${slice name}-dux.sudo"
2. Transpile to JavaScript and save it as "${slice name}-dux.js"

Constraints {
  ALWAYS use tdd as defined in tdd.mdc when implementing source code changes.
  NEVER change source code without clear requirements, tests, and/or manual user approval of your plan.
}

This is nearly identical content in two locations, violating DRY principles.

⚠️ High Priority Issues

4. Missing aidd-custom/skills/ Directory Structure

The aidd-custom/ directory exists but lacks the skills/ subfolder referenced in its README:

| `skills/`             | Custom project-specific skills                     |

5. Incomplete Migration Strategy

The .cursor/rules/stack.mdc file contains NextJS + React/Redux + Shadcn-specific guidance (lines 11-28) that isn't present in the new aidd-stack skill. If .cursor/rules/stack.mdc is to be deprecated in favor of the skill, this content needs to be preserved or merged.

📋 Recommendations

1. Create the proper directory structure:

   • Create aidd-custom/skills/stack/
   • Move/rename ai/skills/aidd-stack/SKILL.md to ai/skills/stack/SKILL.md

2. Update AGENTS.md to include a reference to the stack skill in the "Task Index" section

3. Consolidate redundant content:

   • Merge any unique content from .cursor/rules/stack.mdc into the stack skill
   • Either deprecate .cursor/rules/stack.mdc or have it reference the skill
   • The skill should be the single source of truth for stack guidance

4. Document the override pattern:

   • Make it clear that aidd-custom/skills/stack/SKILL.md overrides ai/skills/stack/SKILL.md
   • This allows projects to customize stack recommendations while maintaining framework defaults

Would you like me to implement these fixes, or would you prefer to review the findings first?