Repository navigation
tooling(pm): dispatch-gates.mjs — the gate roster moves out as data, the engine keeps load / match / derive, the self-test splits fast / slow, derivation byte-identical (W3 of the skills-lane diet program, ruled A; carries the --tier note remainder) #22478
Description
Activity
Claim: PM loop round 3
Session:session_01JmWtcHfGbC4ncw4GFKWuRA
Account:os-elon-musk(the seat's linked user asGET /useranswers it; always the card's assignee)
Branch:claude/issue-22478-dispatch-gates-roster-split
Worktree:objectstack-issue-22478
Domain:domain:skills
Seat:domain:skills#1
File surface:scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs(30,049 lines onorigin/maindee7692f; the ruling-208 freeze is LIFTED for exactly this split by the maintainer's letter A on #22453 — 「同意」, 6079780639 — and restores itself when this PR lands), the new data file(s) beside it for what moves out as data (the hand-written ledgers and grammars the engine reads, and whatever the dev measures the roster to be — the card's premise that the roster is a path → family table is itself measured first: the families are derived from the tree's workflows andpackage.json, so the roster may already be data and the split then moves the ledgers, fixtures and the self-test out of the engine file),scripts/pm/check-dispatch-gates.mjsandpackage.json:79only if the fast / slow tiers need their own entry points, and nothing else. Both occurrences of the--tiernote (lines 12488 and 12900, "changes contract accept/reject behaviour") reworded to ruling C's meaning — the PR carriesFixes #22478andFixes #22167. The ruling's three conditions are the acceptance: coverage of every derivation path measured and pinned BEFORE the split; the printed output of--commands,--tierand--ranbyte-identical before and after over the fixture corpus plus this lane's three 2026-10-09 change sets, with the battery's seconds per tier before and after beside it; nothing else in the file under the lift. ⛔ No new gate family, no ratchet, no patrol line (ruling 208's 「⛔ 无原话不新增」 stands); ⛔ no edit to.claude/**(the freeze line ininstrument-discipline.md:10stays as written). Stop on breach; explain in the report.
Container & model:L,mode:subagent,model: CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER(the MANDATORY line read:dispatch-gates --tier --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs package.json⇢ "no path-derived mandate: the surface hits none of the 3 declared glob(s)"; reason: the seat's proactive upgrade — this instrument derives every card's gate families and the model tier itself, so a mis-split silently drops families or tiers for every later dispatch; a 30,049-line refactor with byte-identical pins is not the one-line mechanical class)
Clause-②: no
Responsibility: n/a — not a defect card (a maintainer-ruled refactor: W3 of #22060 under #22453's letter A)
Thread-read: none
Serial constraints cleared: #22451 is in flight on the same file (branchcfff9b1apushed, PR pending: exactly one pin at line 26400,HUMAN_MERGE_LINE_THRESHOLD5,000 → 3,000) — parallel authoring, SERIAL landing: this card's branch mergesorigin/mainafter #22451 lands and never rewrites that pin's meaning; #22452 (W1, queued) touchescheck-skill-line-ratchet.mjsandplatform-readings.md, off this surface; no open PR touchesscripts/pm/**(10 open PRs' file lists read at 2026-10-09T12:07Z; PR #22460 landed since); verify lock reads LOCKED (the #22451 battery) — the dev takes the lock protocol asos-verify-lock.shprescribes; the lane holds no open p1. Readings at 2026-10-09T12:23Z.os-dev-report
{ "issue": 22478, "status": "done", "branch": "claude/issue-22478-dispatch-gates-roster-split", "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectstack/pull/22531", "head": "10274911 (origin/main ee8751d4 merged on top of 8f1979ee; my five files unchanged by the merge)", "session": "session_01JmWtcHfGbC4ncw4GFKWuRA", "premise_still_valid": true, "summary": "Five commits on origin/main e148ca98 (the landed #22451 pin merged first, its meaning kept). (a) 44d264ed: condition 1 — V8 block coverage over a full run of the battery, parent and 59 CLI children merged: 245 of 245 engine declarations invoked, 253 of 2,259 blocks at zero (V8 semantics: unlisted blocks inherit the enclosing count); 59 in-process pins added for the derivation paths among them (marker-grammar refusals, the matcher floor, the tier renderer's two exits, the changed-line reading's three states, the sister-repo tier run, the claim-line reader, the argv splitter, the repo assertion's refusals, the absent-path verdict, and every class of the run-record reconciliation); battery 2,070 pass. (b) 3cbaf471: the roster was measured to be DERIVED from the workflows (no table exists; mechanism assumption 1 confirmed), so what moved as data is the hand-written tables — marker grammar vocabularies, four ledgers, the change-kind roster, the tier globs, the ladder words — into dispatch-gates.data.mjs (1,258 lines, no logic: predicates/tiers/exceptions named by key and resolved at load with a loud refusal); the battery moved into dispatch-gates.self-test.mjs (13,496 lines) with a FAST tier (every in-process case, 1,811 cases, 283.8 s on this contended box) and a SLOW tier (six named sections: CLI spawns, temporary repos, whole-tree sweeps); the wrapper runs fast on a dev box, both under GITHUB_ACTIONS or --slow, so lint.yml and package.json:79 are untouched and no new family enters the derivation; engine 30,050 → 15,915 lines. (c) 2a5b52c4: the --tier note's three spellings reworded to ruling C's meaning (widening only); grep of the old phrase → 0. (d) c45ee314: the sibling gate check-ratchet-remedy-authority's known-instance row for the engine turns excluded (the token moved with the roster; its own positive control reddened and prescribes correcting the entry). (e) 8f1979ee: the three load-time binders become exported functions (same behaviour) and 14 pins cover their refusals and the fallback fragments the second coverage reading listed. Byte-identical derivation proven on ONE tree with two engines: comparison worktree at e148ca98, the base engine as an untracked copy beside the split engine, 69 corpus invocations + 8 --ran cards (852 files per side, stdout+stderr+exit): diff -r → exit 0, 0 lines, for the e148 split, again for the committed (b) engine, and again on the merged head (base ee8751d4 = the pre-split engine with the OLD clause-② sentence vs the head engine with commit (c), same tree, 852 files per side: 28 .out files differ, 62 lines, all 62 the clause-② sentence — ruling C's rewording and nothing else; no .err or .exit differs). ⚠ The diff is 29,421 changed lines by construction (13k lines moved out are counted twice), far over HUMAN_MERGE_LINE_THRESHOLD = 3000: this PR lands the way §7(c) says a diff over the line threshold lands (an authorized APPROVED review, or a human merge), not the queue on green alone — the card's 非受管面/席位入队 expectation does not hold for this diff.", "tests": "base battery (origin/main dee7692f, clean wrapper run): 2,011 cases pass, 1,093.7 s; per-tier attribution from a timestamped run of the same base (1,051.3 s): slow sections ≈719 s / fast ≈332 s. commit (a) battery (the original engine + 59 pins): 2,070 cases pass, 1,121.1 s. commit (b) fast tier: 1,811 cases pass in 283.8 s (6 slow sections deferred by name, 0 NOT MEASURED). final head both tiers (pnpm check:pm-dispatch-gates --slow): 2,071 cases pass; fast 1,811 in 274.3 s · slow 260 in 834.0 s; wrapper 1,108.7 s; EXIT=0. final head 8f1979ee both tiers: 2,085 cases pass, fast 1,825 in 271.3 s · slow 260 in 790.4 s, wrapper 1062.0 s, EXIT=0. merged head 10274911 both tiers: 2,085 cases pass, fast 1,825 in 285.9 s · slow 260 in 776.1 s, wrapper 1062.6 s, EXIT=0. wrapper --self-test: green incl. the three tier pins (echo children). byte-identical replay, same tree (comparison worktree at e148ca98, base engine as an untracked copy beside the split engine), 69 corpus invocations + 8 --ran cards (complete/short/coded/refused × 4 renderings + a missing record), stdout+stderr+exit recorded, 852 files per side: diff -r base head → exit 0, 0 lines (legs 1,217 s / 1,222 s). second head leg with the COMMITTED (b) engine 3cbaf471 over the same base leg, both --changed entries re-taken on one tree state: diff -r → exit 0, 0 lines, 852 files per side. (b)→(c) delta over the lane sets + this card + a spec suspect, in --tier/human/--json/--commands: 60 files per side, 10 .out files differ and every differing line is the reworded clause-② sentence or the SUSPECT parenthesis; all --commands outputs identical; (c)→(e) over the same 60 files: 0 lines. coverage: before 245/245 declarations invoked, 253/2,259 blocks at zero (60 processes merged, V8 semantics); after on commit (c): 248/248 invoked, 248/2,274 at zero (the pins closed their targets; the split's three binders added 4 refusal blocks) → commit (e) exports the binders and pins those 4 plus 10 fallback fragments (14 cases); COVERAGE_AFTER_RESULT. gates on the split (worktree): check:nul-bytes ✓, check:entry-guard ✓ (285 files, 224 export bindings inert on import), comment-mask-adoption OK, bare-root-worklist --self-test OK (46 recorded verdicts, none stale/missing/contradicted), check-self-test-wired exit 0, check:pm-skill-id-lint ✓, check:pm-skill-ratchet ✓; eslint over the four files exit 0 (only no-restricted-imports and comment-swallow/no-code-inside-block-comment are on for scripts/pm/*.mjs; no type-aware linting, so no untouched file's verdict can move).", "gates": "on the merged head 10274911 (and before it on 8f1979ee, same result): derived 30 commands on the final head (no-path derivation off the merge base); all run with exits captured before any pipe; non-zero: none; --ran reconciliation exit 0: ✓ dispatch-gates --ran: 30 derived famil(ies) accounted for — 30 run, 0 NOT-MEASURED (a DERIVED zero — all 30 recorded an exit code and none of them is 3).; eslint narrowed to the 4 touched files (JSON: 4 files, 0 errors, 0 warnings; only two per-file rules on for scripts/pm/*.mjs, no type-aware linting, so untouched files cannot move); repo-wide pnpm lint = CI", "line_budget": "engine 30,050 → 15,927; data 0 → 1,258; test modules 0 → 13,538 (59 + 14 pins inside); wrapper 502 → 567; sibling ledger +2/−2; commit (a) added 144 pin lines to the engine before the split; changed lines on the head 29,479 (+15,109/−14,370)", "deviations": "(1) Killed by the 5-hour usage wall TWICE (~13:0xZ and ~17:5xZ); restarted idempotently at ~14:0xZ and ~19:1xZ from the pushed branch and the on-disk ledgers (nothing re-derived from memory; ledgered runs not redone). The second kill took the final-head coverage rerun at 1,990/2,085 cases — reported NOT MEASURED, the (c)-head reading stands as the measured after. (2) The replay corpus is NOT a committed self-test case (the suggested route): the claim's file surface says 'and nothing else', and a golden replay would be a new ratchet reddening on every workflow edit, which ruling 208's 无原话不新增 forbids; the runner is in the PR body, the corpus is read from the committed test module. (3) The wrapper reads GITHUB_ACTIONS to run both tiers in CI without a lint.yml edit — the only shape that keeps the file surface, adds no family and still gives devs the fast tier by default; failure direction is a shorter run that says which tier it was, pinned in both directions. (4) The battery is loaded without a top-level await (the battery imports the engine; awaiting it deadlocks at exit 13). (5) A first same-tree replay (base dee7692f) differed only in the STALE TREE banner on stderr because my own git fetch advanced the shared origin/main between its two legs (29 files × the 3-line banner, 0 stdout/exit differences); the proof replay on e148ca98 was run with no fetch in between. (6) Readings are from a contended 4-core box (load ≈3.4, other batteries concurrent); CI's step log is the runner reading. (7) Commit (d) touches scripts/check-ratchet-remedy-authority.mjs, OFF the declared file surface: its known-instance ledger expected the engine to be `marked` for a token that moved with the change-kind roster into the data file; the gate reddened on this head and its own text says correct the entry — the row turns `excluded` (+2/-2), in its own commit the seat can drop. (8) One refusal text's pointer was updated to the data file (MARKER_COMMENT_FORMS moved there) — a message change, not a derivation change.", "files_changed": [ "scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs", "scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.data.mjs", "scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.self-test.mjs", "scripts/pm/check-dispatch-gates.mjs", "scripts/check-ratchet-remedy-authority.mjs (commit (d): one ledger row, +2/-2, off the declared surface — see deviations)" ], "mcp_calls": "0 — no MCP tool was called; reads were gh api GET; writes were 6 git pushes, one fleet-write dispatch pr_create, one label-write.mjs stroke, one post-stamped.mjs comment", "api_writes": "3 — all through scripts/pm/ as objectstack-fleet[bot] via the fleet-write relay: (1) pr_create objectstack-ai/objectstack#22531 (request fw-20261009T195708Z-d530ad, run 37983703926, read-back 43468 bytes sent = 43468 stored); (2) label-write.mjs one stroke on #22531: labels_add skip-changeset + assign os-elon-musk (run 37983803113, read-back matches: labels size/xl + skip-changeset, assignee os-elon-musk); (3) post-stamped.mjs: this os-dev-report comment on #22478. Reads were gh api GET only. git push: 6 (the empty-branch probe, (a), (b)+(c), (d), (e), the merge of origin/main) — not REST, not relayed. No PATCH of any body; the PR was never flipped ready.", "open_questions": [], "out_of_scope_findings": [ "observation (not filed): dispatch-gates.mjs's baseDrift() reads the shared refs/remotes/origin/main, so any fetch in a sibling worktree changes the STALE TREE banner mid-session — AGENTS.md's shared-ref hazard, seen live; reach: stderr prose only; carrier: none", "observation (not filed): the 5,000→3,000 human-merge threshold makes any refactor that moves a large self-test out of a file land by approved review or human merge by construction — a property of counting additions + deletions, not a defect; carrier: the seat's routing of this PR" ] }
Generated by Claude Code
os-dev-report
{ "issue": 22478, "status": "done", "branch": "claude/issue-22478-dispatch-gates-roster-split", "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectstack/pull/22531", "head": "10274911 (origin/main ee8751d4 merged on top of 8f1979ee; my five files unchanged by the merge)", "session": "session_01JmWtcHfGbC4ncw4GFKWuRA", "premise_still_valid": true, "summary": "Five commits on origin/main e148ca98 (the landed #22451 pin merged first, its meaning kept). (a) 44d264ed: condition 1 — V8 block coverage over a full run of the battery, parent and 59 CLI children merged: 245 of 245 engine declarations invoked, 253 of 2,259 blocks at zero (V8 semantics: unlisted blocks inherit the enclosing count); 59 in-process pins added for the derivation paths among them (marker-grammar refusals, the matcher floor, the tier renderer's two exits, the changed-line reading's three states, the sister-repo tier run, the claim-line reader, the argv splitter, the repo assertion's refusals, the absent-path verdict, and every class of the run-record reconciliation); battery 2,070 pass. (b) 3cbaf471: the roster was measured to be DERIVED from the workflows (no table exists; mechanism assumption 1 confirmed), so what moved as data is the hand-written tables — marker grammar vocabularies, four ledgers, the change-kind roster, the tier globs, the ladder words — into dispatch-gates.data.mjs (1,258 lines, no logic: predicates/tiers/exceptions named by key and resolved at load with a loud refusal); the battery moved into dispatch-gates.self-test.mjs (13,496 lines) with a FAST tier (every in-process case, 1,811 cases, 283.8 s on this contended box) and a SLOW tier (six named sections: CLI spawns, temporary repos, whole-tree sweeps); the wrapper runs fast on a dev box, both under GITHUB_ACTIONS or --slow, so lint.yml and package.json:79 are untouched and no new family enters the derivation; engine 30,050 → 15,915 lines. (c) 2a5b52c4: the --tier note's three spellings reworded to ruling C's meaning (widening only); grep of the old phrase → 0. (d) c45ee314: the sibling gate check-ratchet-remedy-authority's known-instance row for the engine turns excluded (the token moved with the roster; its own positive control reddened and prescribes correcting the entry). (e) 8f1979ee: the three load-time binders become exported functions (same behaviour) and 14 pins cover their refusals and the fallback fragments the second coverage reading listed. Byte-identical derivation proven on ONE tree with two engines: comparison worktree at e148ca98, the base engine as an untracked copy beside the split engine, 69 corpus invocations + 8 --ran cards (852 files per side, stdout+stderr+exit): diff -r → exit 0, 0 lines, for the e148 split, again for the committed (b) engine, and again on the merged head (base ee8751d4 = the pre-split engine with the OLD clause-② sentence vs the head engine with commit (c), same tree, 852 files per side: 28 .out files differ, 62 lines, all 62 the clause-② sentence — ruling C's rewording and nothing else; no .err or .exit differs). ⚠ The diff is 29,421 changed lines by construction (13k lines moved out are counted twice), far over HUMAN_MERGE_LINE_THRESHOLD = 3000: this PR lands the way §7(c) says a diff over the line threshold lands (an authorized APPROVED review, or a human merge), not the queue on green alone — the card's 非受管面/席位入队 expectation does not hold for this diff.", "tests": "base battery (origin/main dee7692f, clean wrapper run): 2,011 cases pass, 1,093.7 s; per-tier attribution from a timestamped run of the same base (1,051.3 s): slow sections ≈719 s / fast ≈332 s. commit (a) battery (the original engine + 59 pins): 2,070 cases pass, 1,121.1 s. commit (b) fast tier: 1,811 cases pass in 283.8 s (6 slow sections deferred by name, 0 NOT MEASURED). final head both tiers (pnpm check:pm-dispatch-gates --slow): 2,071 cases pass; fast 1,811 in 274.3 s · slow 260 in 834.0 s; wrapper 1,108.7 s; EXIT=0. final head 8f1979ee both tiers: 2,085 cases pass, fast 1,825 in 271.3 s · slow 260 in 790.4 s, wrapper 1062.0 s, EXIT=0. merged head 10274911 both tiers: 2,085 cases pass, fast 1,825 in 285.9 s · slow 260 in 776.1 s, wrapper 1062.6 s, EXIT=0. wrapper --self-test: green incl. the three tier pins (echo children). byte-identical replay, same tree (comparison worktree at e148ca98, base engine as an untracked copy beside the split engine), 69 corpus invocations + 8 --ran cards (complete/short/coded/refused × 4 renderings + a missing record), stdout+stderr+exit recorded, 852 files per side: diff -r base head → exit 0, 0 lines (legs 1,217 s / 1,222 s). second head leg with the COMMITTED (b) engine 3cbaf471 over the same base leg, both --changed entries re-taken on one tree state: diff -r → exit 0, 0 lines, 852 files per side. (b)→(c) delta over the lane sets + this card + a spec suspect, in --tier/human/--json/--commands: 60 files per side, 10 .out files differ and every differing line is the reworded clause-② sentence or the SUSPECT parenthesis; all --commands outputs identical; (c)→(e) over the same 60 files: 0 lines. coverage: before 245/245 declarations invoked, 253/2,259 blocks at zero (60 processes merged, V8 semantics); after on commit (c): 248/248 invoked, 248/2,274 at zero (the pins closed their targets; the split's three binders added 4 refusal blocks) → commit (e) exports the binders and pins those 4 plus 10 fallback fragments (14 cases); final head: NOT MEASURED - the full-battery coverage rerun after commit (e) was killed with the session by the second usage wall at 1,990/2,085 cases (child files landed, the parent's never did) and was not re-run on the merged head; the (c)-head reading stands as the measured after, and commit (e)'s 14 pins name their targets by function and branch, each passing in the battery. gates on the split (worktree): check:nul-bytes ✓, check:entry-guard ✓ (285 files, 224 export bindings inert on import), comment-mask-adoption OK, bare-root-worklist --self-test OK (46 recorded verdicts, none stale/missing/contradicted), check-self-test-wired exit 0, check:pm-skill-id-lint ✓, check:pm-skill-ratchet ✓; eslint over the four files exit 0 (only no-restricted-imports and comment-swallow/no-code-inside-block-comment are on for scripts/pm/*.mjs; no type-aware linting, so no untouched file's verdict can move).", "gates": "on the merged head 10274911 (and before it on 8f1979ee, same result): derived 30 commands on the final head (no-path derivation off the merge base); all run with exits captured before any pipe; non-zero: none; --ran reconciliation exit 0: ✓ dispatch-gates --ran: 30 derived famil(ies) accounted for — 30 run, 0 NOT-MEASURED (a DERIVED zero — all 30 recorded an exit code and none of them is 3).; eslint narrowed to the 4 touched files (JSON: 4 files, 0 errors, 0 warnings; only two per-file rules on for scripts/pm/*.mjs, no type-aware linting, so untouched files cannot move); repo-wide pnpm lint = CI", "line_budget": "engine 30,050 → 15,927; data 0 → 1,258; test modules 0 → 13,538 (59 + 14 pins inside); wrapper 502 → 567; sibling ledger +2/−2; commit (a) added 144 pin lines to the engine before the split; changed lines on the head 29,479 (+15,109/−14,370)", "deviations": "(1) Killed by the 5-hour usage wall TWICE (~13:0xZ and ~17:5xZ); restarted idempotently at ~14:0xZ and ~19:1xZ from the pushed branch and the on-disk ledgers (nothing re-derived from memory; ledgered runs not redone). The second kill took the final-head coverage rerun at 1,990/2,085 cases — reported NOT MEASURED, the (c)-head reading stands as the measured after. (2) The replay corpus is NOT a committed self-test case (the suggested route): the claim's file surface says 'and nothing else', and a golden replay would be a new ratchet reddening on every workflow edit, which ruling 208's 无原话不新增 forbids; the runner is in the PR body, the corpus is read from the committed test module. (3) The wrapper reads GITHUB_ACTIONS to run both tiers in CI without a lint.yml edit — the only shape that keeps the file surface, adds no family and still gives devs the fast tier by default; failure direction is a shorter run that says which tier it was, pinned in both directions. (4) The battery is loaded without a top-level await (the battery imports the engine; awaiting it deadlocks at exit 13). (5) A first same-tree replay (base dee7692f) differed only in the STALE TREE banner on stderr because my own git fetch advanced the shared origin/main between its two legs (29 files × the 3-line banner, 0 stdout/exit differences); the proof replay on e148ca98 was run with no fetch in between. (6) Readings are from a contended 4-core box (load ≈3.4, other batteries concurrent); CI's step log is the runner reading. (7) Commit (d) touches scripts/check-ratchet-remedy-authority.mjs, OFF the declared file surface: its known-instance ledger expected the engine to be `marked` for a token that moved with the change-kind roster into the data file; the gate reddened on this head and its own text says correct the entry — the row turns `excluded` (+2/-2), in its own commit the seat can drop. (8) The first os-dev-report comment (6088284655) shipped with a literal placeholder token in its tests field; this corrected comment supersedes it, and the second report write is over budget and listed under api_writes. (9) One refusal text's pointer was updated to the data file (MARKER_COMMENT_FORMS moved there) — a message change, not a derivation change.", "files_changed": [ "scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs", "scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.data.mjs", "scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.self-test.mjs", "scripts/pm/check-dispatch-gates.mjs", "scripts/check-ratchet-remedy-authority.mjs (commit (d): one ledger row, +2/-2, off the declared surface — see deviations)" ], "mcp_calls": "0 — no MCP tool was called; reads were gh api GET; writes were 6 git pushes, one fleet-write dispatch pr_create, one label-write.mjs stroke, one post-stamped.mjs comment", "api_writes": "4 — all through scripts/pm/ as objectstack-fleet[bot] via the fleet-write relay: (1) pr_create objectstack-ai/objectstack#22531 (request fw-20261009T195708Z-d530ad, run 37983703926, read-back 43468 bytes sent = 43468 stored); (2) label-write.mjs one stroke on #22531: labels_add skip-changeset + assign os-elon-musk (run 37983803113, read-back matches: labels size/xl + skip-changeset, assignee os-elon-musk); (3) post-stamped.mjs: a first os-dev-report comment on #22478 (id 6088284655, relay run 37983916138) that carried one stray placeholder token in its tests field; (4) post-stamped.mjs: THIS corrected os-dev-report comment - one write over the four-write budget, spent so the authoritative record is right; the PM reads the newest os-dev-report. Reads were gh api GET only. git push: 6 (the empty-branch probe, (a), (b)+(c), (d), (e), the merge of origin/main) — not REST, not relayed. No PATCH of any body; the PR was never flipped ready.", "open_questions": [], "out_of_scope_findings": [ "observation (not filed): dispatch-gates.mjs's baseDrift() reads the shared refs/remotes/origin/main, so any fetch in a sibling worktree changes the STALE TREE banner mid-session — AGENTS.md's shared-ref hazard, seen live; reach: stderr prose only; carrier: none", "observation (not filed): the 5,000→3,000 human-merge threshold makes any refactor that moves a large self-test out of a file land by approved review or human merge by construction — a property of counting additions + deletions, not a defect; carrier: the seat's routing of this PR" ] }
Generated by Claude Code
ACCEPT — PR #22531 (head
10274911), over the human-merge line, the four-piece set posted, landing on the maintainer's APPROVED — skills seat 1,session_01JmWtcHfGbC4ncw4GFKWuRA, 2026-10-09T20:12ZVerified on GitHub and on the fetched branch, not on the report: a draft PR against
main, first linesFixes #22478andFixes #22167, 5 files (+15,109/−14,370; 29,479 changed lines, 13k of them moved and counted twice): the hand-written tables out asdispatch-gates.data.mjs(1,258 lines, no logic), the battery out asdispatch-gates.self-test.mjs(13,538 lines, fast / slow tiers), the engine 30,049 → 15,927 lines, the wrapper running the fast tier on a dev box and both tiers in CI, one sibling ledger row following the move; the--tiernote reworded to ruling C's meaning (old phrase 0 hits); #22451's pin kept at 3000 / 3001 in the moved self-test;package.jsonand the workflows untouched. The roster was measured to be derived from the workflows (the card's premise corrected, no second roster invented). Condition 2 holds twice: the dev's same-tree replay (852 files per side,diff -r0 lines) and the seat's own probe (base engine vs head engine over PR #22490's seven paths and the automation skill's two:--commandsbyte-identical,--tieridentical but for the reworded sentence). Condition 1: coverage read before the split (245/245 declarations, 253/2,259 blocks at zero), 59 + 14 pins added, after-reading on the (c) head 248/2,274; the final-head rerun NOT MEASURED (the second wall). Battery on the merged head 2,085 cases, fast 285.9 s / slow 776.1 s, exit 0; the gate union pinned to10274911(30 families,--ran30/30, all exit 0).mcp_calls0;api_writes4 relay strokes (pr_create, label-write, two report comments — the second supersedes a placeholder in the first). Commits authored byobjectstack-fleet[bot]. Deviations accepted as listed in the review record.Contract review PASS in seat at tier: 6088468843. Landing: the diff is over the 3,000-line human-merge line (in force since PR #22490 landed at 14:44Z), so it lands by §7(c) — the four-piece set is posted in this act (this ACCEPT, the review record,
needs-user-decision+ 维护者速读 on the PR, review requested fromos-zhuangandhotlongthrough the relay); on an authorized APPROVED the seat lands unless the approver already did; close-out is the seat's either way, and closes #22167 with it. The freeze ondispatch-gates.mjsis back as ruling 208 states it the moment this lands.Landed — PR #22531 MERGED on the approver's own arm, the card closed by
Fixes(#22167 with it) — skills seat 1,session_01JmWtcHfGbC4ncw4GFKWuRA, 2026-10-10T00:43ZThree readings, taken together: PR #22531 reads
merged: trueat 2026-10-10T00:40Z (commit6a3f82efa7d588267eb2e52c06a73c56315c636a, merged through the merge queue afteros-zhuang's APPROVED 2026-10-10T00:04Z — review 5476495352, on the head10274911— and their own ready flip, arm and enqueue within two minutes of it; 34 minutes in the queue), that commit is an ancestor oforigin/mainas fetched in this act, and the five files onorigin/mainare byte-identical to the PR head10274911.scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjsis 15,927 lines onmain, besidedispatch-gates.data.mjs(1,258 lines, no logic) anddispatch-gates.self-test.mjs(13,538 lines, fast / slow tiers);check-dispatch-gates.mjsruns the fast tier on a dev box and both tiers underGITHUB_ACTIONSor--slow; the--tiernote reads ruling C's meaning (closes #22167); #22451's 3,000-line pin sits in the moved self-test. The ruling-208 freeze ondispatch-gates.mjsis restored from this commit: the lift at #22453 (letter A) was for exactly this split, and the split has landed.Over-the-line landing (29,479 changed lines against the 3,000-line human-merge line) by the maintainer's authorized approval on this seat's four-piece set (contract review PASS 6088468843 with one declared seat probe, ACCEPT 6088478671, 维护者速读 6088486216, review requested from both authorized approvers). The card closed
completedbyFixes, #22167 with it (its claim for this branch: 6088380960);pm:dispatchedand the assignee are stripped from both cards in this act, and so is the PR'sneeds-user-decision. Carried, NOT MEASURED: the post-split coverage battery's rerun on the final head (the second usage wall killed it at 1,818 of 2,071 cases; the before / after readings — 245/245 declarations, 253 → 248 zero blocks — stand on the head one commit earlier); the next dev on the self-test takes that reading with their first fast-tier run. Timings: claim → draft PR 7 h 31 min across two usage walls; four-piece set → APPROVED 3 h 52 min; APPROVED → MERGED 36 min. Nothing else is owed on this card; the lane's next card near these files, #22452 (W1, queued), does not touch the engine.
Guards: ruling 208 — 「工具位只有一个,先花在删除上;
dispatch-gates.mjs冻结,只在它喂的 workflow 坏了时碰」 (references/instrument-discipline.md:10) — lifted for exactly this split by the maintainer's letter A on #22453 (「同意」, 2026-10-09T11:15Z, record 6079780639, batch #303 item 1) and restored as stated the moment this card's PR lands; the lift's three conditions are this card's acceptance, nothing else in the file changes under it.Filing gate: ③ a maintainer-directed task — work item W3 of the program anchor #22060, ruled A at #22453. Part of #22060 — this card closes on its own PR; the same PR carries
Fixes #22167(ruling C's remainder: the--tiernote in this file reworded to the same meaning, both occurrences). Reader: thedomain:skillsseat dispatches it to one os-dev; the surface isscripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjsplus the new roster data file beside it (andpackage.json'scheck:pm-dispatch-gatesline if the two tiers need two scripts) — off the governed register, so CI green + the seat's at-tier read lands it through the queue. Filed by skills seat 1 (seat post #7623,session_01JmWtcHfGbC4ncw4GFKWuRA). Dedupe: the decision #22453 (ruled, closed on this filing), the anchor #22060 (W3 row), #22167 (pm:blockedon this card), #21719 (closed, the same lock hold measured); REST listinglabels=toolingsince 2026-09-20 titles grepped fordispatch-gates|roster|split|freeze→ nothing else; the global search endpoint is not reachable from a seat container.What is measured (
origin/main, 2026-10-09)scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjsis 30,049 lines (wc -l); the second-largest pm instrument,check-half-states.mjs, is 34,938.check:pm-dispatch-gates(package.json:79, 2,011 cases) held the shared verify lock for 842.7 s and 1,023.8 s in the two 2026-10-07 dev reports and for 1,052.1 s, 1,126.6 s and 1,174 s in three 2026-10-09 reports on this lane (concurrent batteries on one box) — every dev delivery on a card touching the file pays it.--tiernote's sentence "changes contract accept/reject behaviour" occurs twice (grep -c), contradictingexecution-duties.md's Clause-② (widening only) — ruling C on [finding] dispatch-gates --tier's Clause-② note says a card that "changes contract accept/reject behaviour" owes a contract review and is spec-lane work; execution-duties.md's Clause-② is widening only, so a narrowing card has two answers #22167; its first half landed as PR docs(pm-dispatch): a card that narrows a published accept set is Clause-② no, stays in its lane and owes one contract-review-tier review before the queue #22223, the remainder waits here.Done when (the ruling's conditions, in its order)
--tier's globs included) and adds a pin for each path they do not; the PR states the coverage before and after and names the pins added.dispatch-gates.mjs; the engine keeps roster loading, path matching and derivation (--commands,--tier,--ranand the readings they print); the file's line count before and after is in the PR. A new gate family is then one data row, ⛔ still only on the maintainer's words (ruling 208's 「⛔ 无原话不新增」 is untouched).Lint & Repo Gatesand on demand); the battery's seconds before and after, per tier, are in the PR; ⛔ no case is dropped, the slow tier stays wired in CI.--commands,--tierand--ranis identical before and after the split; the PR carries the replay and its empty diff.--tiernote is reworded to ruling C's meaning in both occurrences;grep -c "changes contract accept/reject" scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs→ 0; the PR body's first lines areFixes #<this card>andFixes #22167.pnpm check:pm-dispatch-gatesgreen on both tiers;pnpm check:pm-skill-ratchetandcheck:pm-skill-id-lintuntouched and green.Serial constraints
HUMAN_MERGE_LINE_THRESHOLD), per the maintainer's 2026-10-09 ruling #22451 (in flight, PR pending): it moves the one pin at this file's line 26400 (HUMAN_MERGE_LINE_THRESHOLD5,000 → 3,000); this card's branch mergesorigin/mainafter that lands and ⛔ never rewrites that pin's meaning.scripts/pm/check-skill-line-ratchet.mjsis not on this card's surface; tooling(pm): platform-readings.md diet — delete every reading a scripts/pm tool now enforces; tool first, text second (W1 of the skills-lane diet program) #22452 (W1) touches it forplatform-readings.md's ceiling only.Dedupe words:
dispatch-gates roster as data·self-test fast slow tiers·derivation byte-identical split