Skip to content

Fix example CIF files#19

Open
vaitkus wants to merge 6 commits into
COMCIFS:mainfrom
vaitkus:fix-example-cif-files
Open

Fix example CIF files#19
vaitkus wants to merge 6 commits into
COMCIFS:mainfrom
vaitkus:fix-example-cif-files

Conversation

@vaitkus

@vaitkus vaitkus commented Jun 5, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

This set of changes to the example CIF files mostly deals with syntactic issues and straightforward correction to the data names. However, please still review before merging.

Also, there were several syntactic issues which I was unsure on how you would like to be fixed. Your comments on these issue would be appreciated.

1. Examples/02_Org_Multi_Stoich/structure_ranking_methods.cif

Data item _forcefield.long_range_electrostatic appears twice with differing values. The same data item mus appear only once in a data block.

2. Examples/03_Org_ROY/structure_ranking_methods.cif

In both data blocks, data item _forcefield.long_range_electrostatic appears twice with differing values. The same data item mus appear only once in a data block.

3. Examples/03_Org_ROY/structures.cif

Each data block name is followed by two values "New" and a space group symbol, e.g.:
data_0001_Y_Energy_0.000_Density_1.5366 New: P21/n.

Unfortunately, this is not valid CIF syntax. Should the "New: P21/n" part be:
a) Removed.
b) Commented out.
c) Made part of the block name, e.g. data_0001_Y_Energy_0.000_Density_1.5366_New:_P21/n

Does any of these approaches look suitable?

Feel free to modify the files directly in this PR or just let me know how should I resolve these cases.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant