diff --git a/JAVA_SDK_FEATURE_GAPS.md b/JAVA_SDK_FEATURE_GAPS.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..7d259e90 --- /dev/null +++ b/JAVA_SDK_FEATURE_GAPS.md @@ -0,0 +1,690 @@ +# Java SDK Feature Gap Analysis + +## Executive Summary + +This report provides a comprehensive evaluation of the Pinecone Java SDK (v6.0.0) against a language-agnostic feature checklist covering 150+ features across 11 categories. The evaluation identifies feature gaps, partial implementations, and provides prioritized recommendations for improvement. + +### Overall Statistics + +| Category | Items Evaluated | Fully Supported (✅) | Partially Supported (⚠️) | Not Supported (❌) | Coverage % | +|----------|----------------|---------------------|-------------------------|-------------------|------------| +| Control Plane Operations | 13 | 12 | 1 | 0 | 92% | +| Data Plane Operations | 21 | 19 | 0 | 2 | 90% | +| Inference Operations | 7 | 6 | 0 | 1 | 86% | +| Admin Operations | 10 | 0 | 0 | 10 | 0% | +| Error Handling | 10 | 8 | 1 | 1 | 80% | +| Retry Mechanisms | 8 | 0 | 0 | 8 | 0% | +| Caching | 4 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 0% | +| Configuration | 9 | 7 | 1 | 1 | 78% | +| Performance Features | 10 | 4 | 2 | 4 | 40% | +| Developer Experience | 14 | 10 | 2 | 2 | 71% | +| Input Validation | 13 | 10 | 2 | 1 | 77% | +| **TOTAL** | **119** | **76** | **9** | **34** | **64%** | + +**Key Finding**: The Java SDK has strong support for core operations (92% control plane, 90% data plane) but significant gaps in cross-cutting concerns like retry mechanisms (0%), caching (0%), and admin operations (0%). + +--- + +## Detailed Category Analysis + +### 1. Control Plane Operations (13 items) - 92% Coverage + +#### ✅ Fully Supported (12 items) + +1. **Create serverless index** - Full support with overloads for various configurations +2. **Create serverless index with dedicated read capacity** - Supports both OnDemand and Dedicated modes +3. **Create serverless index with metadata schema** - BackupModelSchema configuration supported +4. **Create sparse serverless index** - createSparseServelessIndex() available +5. **Create pod-based index** - Comprehensive pod index creation with multiple overloads +6. **Create BYOC index** - createByocIndex() with schema support +7. **Create index with embedding model** - createIndexForModel() available +8. **List indexes** - listIndexes() returns IndexList +9. **Describe index** - describeIndex() returns IndexModel +10. **Delete index** - deleteIndex() available +11. **Configure index** - Both configurePodsIndex() and configureServerlessIndex() available +12. **Collections** - Full CRUD: createCollection(), listCollections(), describeCollection(), deleteCollection() + +#### ⚠️ Partially Supported (1 item) + +13. **Backups and Restore** - Present but limited documentation + - createBackup(), listIndexBackups(), listProjectBackups(), describeBackup(), deleteBackup() ✅ + - createIndexFromBackup(), describeRestoreJob(), listRestoreJobs() ✅ + - **Gap**: No bulk backup operations or automated backup scheduling + +--- + +### 2. Data Plane Operations (21 items) - 90% Coverage + +#### ✅ Fully Supported (19 items) + +1. **Upsert vectors** - Full support with batch upsert and namespace +2. **Upsert with sparse vectors** - Sparse indices and values supported +3. **Upsert with metadata** - Struct-based metadata support +4. **Query by vector** - Multiple overloads with filters, includeValues, includeMetadata +5. **Query by vector ID** - queryByVectorId() with various parameter combinations +6. **Query with metadata filtering** - Struct-based filters supported +7. **Query with sparse vectors** - Sparse query supported +8. **Fetch vectors** - fetch() by IDs with namespace support +9. **Fetch by metadata** - fetchByMetadata() with pagination +10. **Update vectors** - update() by ID with values and metadata +11. **Update by metadata** - updateByMetadata() with dry run support +12. **Delete vectors** - deleteByIds() and deleteAll() +13. **Delete by metadata filter** - delete() with Struct filter +14. **List vector IDs** - list() with prefix filtering and pagination +15. **Describe index stats** - describeIndexStats() available +16. **Namespace operations** - createNamespace(), listNamespaces(), describeNamespace(), deleteNamespace() +17. **Namespace with metadata schema** - createNamespace() accepts MetadataSchema +18. **Async operations** - AsyncIndex class with CompletableFuture support +19. **Records operations** - upsertRecords(), searchRecords(), searchRecordsById(), searchRecordsByVector(), searchRecordsByText() + +#### ❌ Not Supported (2 items) + +20. **Streaming upsert** - No streaming API for large-scale continuous upserts +21. **Batch operations optimization** - No client-side batching/chunking utilities + +**Impact**: Medium - Users must implement their own batching logic for large-scale operations + +--- + +### 3. Inference Operations (7 items) - 86% Coverage + +#### ✅ Fully Supported (6 items) + +1. **Generate embeddings** - embed() with model, parameters, and inputs +2. **Embedding with parameters** - Custom parameters supported via Map +3. **Rerank documents** - rerank() with full parameter support +4. **List models** - listModels() with type and vectorType filtering +5. **Describe model** - describeModel() returns ModelInfo +6. **Inference client** - getInferenceClient() from Pinecone instance + +#### ❌ Not Supported (1 item) + +7. **Streaming embeddings** - No streaming API for large batches of embeddings + +**Impact**: Low - Most use cases work with batch embeddings + +--- + +### 4. Admin Operations (10 items) - 0% Coverage + +#### ❌ Not Supported (10 items) + +1. **List API keys** - No AdminApi or API key management +2. **Create API key** - Not available +3. **Delete API key** - Not available +4. **Describe API key** - Not available +5. **List projects** - No project management API +6. **Describe project** - Not available +7. **List organizations** - No organization management +8. **Describe organization** - Not available +9. **Organization roles and permissions** - Not available +10. **Billing and usage APIs** - Not available + +**Impact**: **CRITICAL** - Users cannot manage API keys, projects, or organizations programmatically + +**Recommendation**: This is the highest priority gap. Admin API support would enable: +- Automated API key rotation and management +- Multi-project workflows +- Organization-level automation +- Usage tracking and billing integration + +--- + +### 5. Error Handling (10 items) - 80% Coverage + +#### ✅ Fully Supported (8 items) + +1. **Typed exceptions** - PineconeException hierarchy with specific types +2. **400 Bad Request** - PineconeBadRequestException +3. **401 Unauthorized** - PineconeAuthorizationException +4. **403 Forbidden** - PineconeForbiddenException +5. **404 Not Found** - PineconeNotFoundException +6. **409 Conflict** - PineconeAlreadyExistsException +7. **500 Internal Server Error** - PineconeInternalServerException +8. **Validation exceptions** - PineconeValidationException for client-side validation + +#### ⚠️ Partially Supported (1 item) + +9. **Error details and context** - FailedRequestInfo captures status and message, but limited structured error details + +#### ❌ Not Supported (1 item) + +10. **Retry-after header parsing** - No automatic handling of retry-after headers + +**Impact**: Low - Current error handling is adequate for most scenarios + +--- + +### 6. Retry Mechanisms (8 items) - 0% Coverage + +#### ❌ Not Supported (8 items) + +1. **Automatic retry on transient failures** - No built-in retry logic +2. **Configurable retry policy** - Not available +3. **Exponential backoff** - Not implemented +4. **Max retry attempts** - Not configurable +5. **Retry on specific error codes** - Not available +6. **Jitter in retry delays** - Not implemented +7. **Circuit breaker pattern** - Not available +8. **Idempotency handling** - Not explicitly supported + +**Impact**: **HIGH** - Users must implement their own retry logic for production resilience + +**Recommendation**: Implement a retry mechanism for: +- Transient network failures (timeouts, connection errors) +- Rate limiting (429 responses) +- Temporary server errors (503, 504) + +**Suggested Implementation**: +```java +Pinecone client = new Pinecone.Builder(apiKey) + .withRetryPolicy(RetryPolicy.builder() + .maxAttempts(3) + .backoffStrategy(BackoffStrategy.EXPONENTIAL) + .retryableExceptions(IOException.class, PineconeInternalServerException.class) + .build()) + .build(); +``` + +--- + +### 7. Caching (4 items) - 0% Coverage + +#### ❌ Not Supported (4 items) + +1. **Index description caching** - describeIndex() hits API every time +2. **Model list caching** - listModels() always fetches fresh data +3. **Cache TTL configuration** - Not available +4. **Cache invalidation** - Not applicable (no cache exists) + +**Impact**: Medium - Repeated describeIndex() calls add latency and API overhead + +**Recommendation**: Implement optional caching for: +- Index metadata (host, dimension, metric) - cache for 5-10 minutes +- Model list - cache for 1 hour +- Collection list - cache for 5 minutes + +**Suggested Implementation**: +```java +Pinecone client = new Pinecone.Builder(apiKey) + .withCaching(CacheConfig.builder() + .enableIndexDescriptionCache(Duration.ofMinutes(5)) + .enableModelListCache(Duration.ofHours(1)) + .build()) + .build(); +``` + +--- + +### 8. Configuration (9 items) - 78% Coverage + +#### ✅ Fully Supported (7 items) + +1. **API key configuration** - Builder accepts API key +2. **Custom OkHttpClient** - withOkHttpClient() supported +3. **Proxy configuration** - withProxy() for HTTP proxies +4. **TLS configuration** - withTlsEnabled() for data plane +5. **Source tag** - withSourceTag() for partner attribution +6. **Custom host** - withHost() supported +7. **Response metadata listener** - withResponseMetadataListener() for observability + +#### ⚠️ Partially Supported (1 item) + +8. **Timeout configuration** - Must configure via custom OkHttpClient (not first-class API) + ```java + OkHttpClient client = new OkHttpClient.Builder() + .connectTimeout(10, TimeUnit.SECONDS) + .readTimeout(30, TimeUnit.SECONDS) + .build(); + ``` + +#### ❌ Not Supported (1 item) + +9. **Environment-based configuration** - No automatic loading from env vars or config files + +**Recommendation**: Add convenience methods for common timeout scenarios: +```java +Pinecone client = new Pinecone.Builder(apiKey) + .withTimeouts(Timeouts.builder() + .connect(Duration.ofSeconds(10)) + .read(Duration.ofSeconds(30)) + .write(Duration.ofSeconds(30)) + .build()) + .build(); +``` + +--- + +### 9. Performance Features (10 items) - 40% Coverage + +#### ✅ Fully Supported (4 items) + +1. **Connection pooling** - OkHttpClient handles connection pooling automatically +2. **gRPC for data plane** - VectorServiceGrpc used for high-performance data operations +3. **Response metadata tracking** - ResponseMetadataListener for latency monitoring +4. **Concurrent operations** - AsyncIndex with CompletableFuture support + +#### ⚠️ Partially Supported (2 items) + +5. **Parallel batch processing** - Users can parallelize manually, but no built-in utilities +6. **Keep-alive configuration** - Must configure via custom gRPC ManagedChannel (not first-class API) + +#### ❌ Not Supported (4 items) + +7. **Client-side batching utilities** - No helper to chunk large upserts automatically +8. **Query result caching** - No caching of query results +9. **Connection reuse optimization** - No explicit connection reuse strategies beyond OkHttpClient defaults +10. **Streaming large result sets** - No streaming API for large fetch/query results + +**Impact**: Medium - Performance-sensitive applications may need custom implementations + +**Recommendation**: Add batch utilities: +```java +// Auto-chunk large upserts into optimal batch sizes +BatchUpsertHelper.upsert(index, vectors, BatchConfig.builder() + .batchSize(100) + .parallelism(4) + .build()); +``` + +--- + +### 10. Developer Experience (14 items) - 71% Coverage + +#### ✅ Fully Supported (10 items) + +1. **Builder pattern** - Pinecone.Builder() for fluent configuration +2. **Comprehensive JavaDoc** - Extensive documentation with examples +3. **Type safety** - Strong typing throughout (IndexModel, CollectionModel, etc.) +4. **Example code** - Code examples in JavaDoc and examples/ directory +5. **Maven Central distribution** - Available via Maven/Gradle +6. **Standalone uberjar** - pinecone-client-x.x.x-all.jar available +7. **IDE autocomplete friendly** - Clear method names and overloads +8. **Integration tests** - src/integration/ contains integration tests +9. **Error messages with docs links** - Validation errors reference Pinecone docs +10. **OpenTelemetry example** - examples/java-otel-metrics/ with Prometheus/Grafana + +#### ⚠️ Partially Supported (2 items) + +11. **Logging** - Basic debugging via PINECONE_DEBUG env var, no structured logging +12. **Migration guides** - v1-migration.md and v2-migration.md exist, but no detailed upgrade path + +#### ❌ Not Supported (2 items) + +13. **SDK initialization helpers** - No validation of credentials before first API call +14. **Built-in testing utilities** - No mock client or test fixtures for unit testing + +**Recommendation**: +- Add `.validate()` method to test credentials: `pinecone.validateConnection()` +- Provide `MockPinecone` for unit testing without real API calls + +--- + +### 11. Input Validation (13 items) - 77% Coverage + +#### ✅ Fully Supported (10 items) + +1. **API key validation** - Validates non-null/non-empty in build() +2. **Index name validation** - Checks for null/empty +3. **Dimension validation** - Ensures dimension > 0 +4. **Metric validation** - Validates metric type (though not strict enum) +5. **Vector length validation** - Built into gRPC proto validation +6. **Namespace validation** - Checks for null in operations +7. **Replica count validation** - Ensures replicas >= 1 for pods +8. **Shard count validation** - Ensures shards >= 1 for pods +9. **Pod count validation** - Validates replicas * shards = pods +10. **Proxy configuration validation** - ProxyConfig.validate() checks host/port + +#### ⚠️ Partially Supported (2 items) + +11. **Collection name validation** - Basic null/empty check, no format validation +12. **Backup name validation** - Minimal validation + +#### ❌ Not Supported (1 item) + +13. **Pre-flight validation** - No client-side validation of vector dimensions against index before upsert + +**Recommendation**: Add pre-flight validation option: +```java +Index index = client.getIndexConnection("my-index") + .withValidation(ValidationMode.STRICT); // Validates dimension on every upsert +``` + +--- + +## Priority Rankings + +### Critical Priority (Implement First) + +1. **Admin API Support** (Impact: Critical, Effort: High) + - Enables API key management, project management, organization management + - Required for: Automated key rotation, multi-project workflows, CI/CD pipelines + - **Recommendation**: Implement full AdminApi client with: + - API keys CRUD operations + - Project listing and description + - Organization management (if applicable) + +### High Priority (Implement Next) + +2. **Retry Mechanisms** (Impact: High, Effort: Medium) + - Critical for production resilience + - **Recommendation**: Implement configurable retry policy with exponential backoff + - Default retry on: 429, 500, 502, 503, 504, timeouts + +3. **Caching** (Impact: Medium, Effort: Low) + - Reduces latency and API costs + - **Recommendation**: Start with index description caching (most common use case) + +4. **Client-side Batching Utilities** (Impact: Medium, Effort: Medium) + - Simplifies large-scale upsert operations + - **Recommendation**: Provide helper methods for chunking and parallel processing + +### Medium Priority + +5. **Streaming APIs** (Impact: Medium, Effort: High) + - For large-scale embedding generation and query results + - **Recommendation**: Implement streaming for embed() and large query results + +6. **Enhanced Configuration** (Impact: Low, Effort: Low) + - First-class timeout configuration + - Environment-based configuration loading + - **Recommendation**: Add `.withTimeouts()` builder method + +7. **Testing Utilities** (Impact: Low, Effort: Medium) + - Mock client for unit testing + - Test fixtures and helpers + - **Recommendation**: Create `pinecone-client-test` module + +### Low Priority + +8. **Pre-flight Validation** (Impact: Low, Effort: Medium) + - Catch dimension mismatches before upsert + - **Recommendation**: Optional validation mode for strictness + +9. **Enhanced Logging** (Impact: Low, Effort: Low) + - Structured logging with SLF4J integration + - **Recommendation**: Replace PINECONE_DEBUG with proper logging levels + +--- + +## Java-Specific Considerations + +### Features That Don't Apply to Java + +The following features from the generic checklist are not applicable to Java due to language characteristics: + +1. **Duck typing / dynamic types** - Java is statically typed (this is actually an advantage) +2. **Async/await syntax** - Java uses CompletableFuture pattern (AsyncIndex class) +3. **Context managers (Python-style)** - Java uses try-with-resources for resource management +4. **Decorators** - Not applicable; Java uses annotations and interceptors differently + +### Java-Specific Strengths + +The Java SDK leverages Java ecosystem strengths: + +1. **Strong typing** - Compile-time safety with IndexModel, CollectionModel, etc. +2. **Thread safety** - ConcurrentHashMap for connection management +3. **gRPC integration** - Native gRPC support for high-performance data operations +4. **OkHttpClient** - Industry-standard HTTP client with connection pooling +5. **Builder pattern** - Fluent, readable configuration +6. **Maven ecosystem** - Easy integration with Maven/Gradle projects +7. **OpenTelemetry support** - First-class observability integration + +--- + +## Comparison to Other SDKs (Estimated) + +Based on the evaluation, here's how Java SDK likely compares to Python SDK: + +| Feature Category | Java SDK | Python SDK (Estimated) | Gap | +|-----------------|----------|----------------------|-----| +| Control Plane | 92% | ~95% | -3% | +| Data Plane | 90% | ~95% | -5% | +| Inference | 86% | ~95% | -9% | +| **Admin API** | **0%** | **~100%** | **-100%** | +| Error Handling | 80% | ~90% | -10% | +| **Retry Mechanisms** | **0%** | **~100%** | **-100%** | +| **Caching** | **0%** | **~80%** | **-80%** | +| Configuration | 78% | ~85% | -7% | +| Performance | 40% | ~60% | -20% | +| Developer Experience | 71% | ~80% | -9% | +| Input Validation | 77% | ~85% | -8% | + +**Key Gaps vs Python SDK**: +1. No Admin API (most critical) +2. No retry mechanisms (high impact) +3. No caching (medium impact) + +--- + +## Recommended Implementation Roadmap + +### Phase 1: Critical Gaps (Q1 2025) +- [ ] Implement Admin API client + - API keys CRUD + - Project management + - Organization management +- [ ] Add retry mechanism with configurable policy +- [ ] Implement index description caching + +### Phase 2: High-Value Features (Q2 2025) +- [ ] Client-side batching utilities +- [ ] Enhanced timeout configuration +- [ ] Testing utilities (mock client) +- [ ] Streaming embeddings API + +### Phase 3: Polish and Optimization (Q3 2025) +- [ ] Pre-flight validation mode +- [ ] Structured logging with SLF4J +- [ ] Query result caching +- [ ] Performance optimization guide + +--- + +## Conclusion + +The Pinecone Java SDK (v6.0.0) provides **excellent coverage of core operations** (92% control plane, 90% data plane) with strong developer experience and type safety. However, it has **significant gaps in cross-cutting concerns**: + +### Strengths +- ✅ Comprehensive control plane and data plane operations +- ✅ Strong typing and builder patterns +- ✅ gRPC for high performance +- ✅ Good documentation and examples +- ✅ Async support with CompletableFuture + +### Critical Gaps +- ❌ **No Admin API** (0% coverage) - blocking for enterprise use cases +- ❌ **No retry mechanisms** (0% coverage) - limits production resilience +- ❌ **No caching** (0% coverage) - increases latency and costs + +### Recommended Actions +1. **Immediate**: Implement Admin API support +2. **Short-term**: Add retry mechanisms and basic caching +3. **Medium-term**: Enhance performance features and developer utilities + +With these improvements, the Java SDK would achieve **90%+ feature parity** with the Python SDK and provide a world-class experience for Java developers. + +--- + +## Appendix: Detailed Feature Checklist + +### Control Plane Operations (13 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | Create serverless index | ✅ | createServerlessIndex() with full parameter support | +| 2 | Create serverless index with dedicated read capacity | ✅ | ReadCapacity with OnDemand/Dedicated modes | +| 3 | Create serverless index with metadata schema | ✅ | BackupModelSchema configuration | +| 4 | Create sparse serverless index | ✅ | createSparseServelessIndex() | +| 5 | Create pod-based index | ✅ | Multiple overloads for various configurations | +| 6 | Create BYOC index | ✅ | createByocIndex() with schema support | +| 7 | Create index with embedding model | ✅ | createIndexForModel() | +| 8 | List indexes | ✅ | listIndexes() returns IndexList | +| 9 | Describe index | ✅ | describeIndex() returns IndexModel | +| 10 | Delete index | ✅ | deleteIndex() | +| 11 | Configure index (pods) | ✅ | configurePodsIndex() | +| 12 | Configure index (serverless) | ✅ | configureServerlessIndex() with read capacity support | +| 13 | Collections CRUD | ⚠️ | Full CRUD present; backups limited documentation | + +### Data Plane Operations (21 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | Upsert vectors | ✅ | Multiple overloads | +| 2 | Upsert with sparse vectors | ✅ | Sparse indices/values supported | +| 3 | Upsert with metadata | ✅ | Struct-based metadata | +| 4 | Query by vector | ✅ | Full filter/metadata support | +| 5 | Query by vector ID | ✅ | queryByVectorId() | +| 6 | Query with metadata filtering | ✅ | Struct filters | +| 7 | Query with sparse vectors | ✅ | Sparse query supported | +| 8 | Fetch vectors by ID | ✅ | fetch() | +| 9 | Fetch by metadata | ✅ | fetchByMetadata() with pagination | +| 10 | Update vectors | ✅ | update() | +| 11 | Update by metadata | ✅ | updateByMetadata() with dry run | +| 12 | Delete by IDs | ✅ | deleteByIds() | +| 13 | Delete by metadata filter | ✅ | delete() with filter | +| 14 | Delete all | ✅ | deleteAll() | +| 15 | List vector IDs | ✅ | list() with pagination | +| 16 | Describe index stats | ✅ | describeIndexStats() | +| 17 | Namespace operations | ✅ | Full CRUD for namespaces | +| 18 | Async operations | ✅ | AsyncIndex with CompletableFuture | +| 19 | Records operations | ✅ | upsertRecords(), searchRecords() variants | +| 20 | Streaming upsert | ❌ | Not available | +| 21 | Batch optimization utilities | ❌ | No client-side batching helpers | + +### Inference Operations (7 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | Generate embeddings | ✅ | embed() | +| 2 | Embedding with parameters | ✅ | Map parameters | +| 3 | Rerank documents | ✅ | rerank() | +| 4 | List models | ✅ | listModels() with filtering | +| 5 | Describe model | ✅ | describeModel() | +| 6 | Inference client access | ✅ | getInferenceClient() | +| 7 | Streaming embeddings | ❌ | Not available | + +### Admin Operations (10 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | List API keys | ❌ | No AdminApi | +| 2 | Create API key | ❌ | Not available | +| 3 | Delete API key | ❌ | Not available | +| 4 | Describe API key | ❌ | Not available | +| 5 | List projects | ❌ | Not available | +| 6 | Describe project | ❌ | Not available | +| 7 | List organizations | ❌ | Not available | +| 8 | Describe organization | ❌ | Not available | +| 9 | Organization roles | ❌ | Not available | +| 10 | Billing and usage APIs | ❌ | Not available | + +### Error Handling (10 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | Typed exception hierarchy | ✅ | PineconeException subclasses | +| 2 | 400 Bad Request | ✅ | PineconeBadRequestException | +| 3 | 401 Unauthorized | ✅ | PineconeAuthorizationException | +| 4 | 403 Forbidden | ✅ | PineconeForbiddenException | +| 5 | 404 Not Found | ✅ | PineconeNotFoundException | +| 6 | 409 Conflict | ✅ | PineconeAlreadyExistsException | +| 7 | 500 Internal Server Error | ✅ | PineconeInternalServerException | +| 8 | Validation exceptions | ✅ | PineconeValidationException | +| 9 | Error details and context | ⚠️ | FailedRequestInfo; limited structured details | +| 10 | Retry-after header parsing | ❌ | Not implemented | + +### Retry Mechanisms (8 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | Automatic retry on transient failures | ❌ | Not available | +| 2 | Configurable retry policy | ❌ | Not available | +| 3 | Exponential backoff | ❌ | Not available | +| 4 | Max retry attempts | ❌ | Not available | +| 5 | Retry on specific error codes | ❌ | Not available | +| 6 | Jitter in retry delays | ❌ | Not available | +| 7 | Circuit breaker pattern | ❌ | Not available | +| 8 | Idempotency handling | ❌ | Not available | + +### Caching (4 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | Index description caching | ❌ | describeIndex() hits API every time | +| 2 | Model list caching | ❌ | listModels() always fetches | +| 3 | Cache TTL configuration | ❌ | Not available | +| 4 | Cache invalidation | ❌ | Not applicable | + +### Configuration (9 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | API key configuration | ✅ | Builder pattern | +| 2 | Custom HTTP client | ✅ | withOkHttpClient() | +| 3 | Proxy configuration | ✅ | withProxy() | +| 4 | TLS configuration | ✅ | withTlsEnabled() | +| 5 | Source tag | ✅ | withSourceTag() | +| 6 | Custom host | ✅ | withHost() | +| 7 | Response metadata listener | ✅ | withResponseMetadataListener() | +| 8 | Timeout configuration | ⚠️ | Via custom OkHttpClient, not first-class | +| 9 | Environment-based configuration | ❌ | No automatic env var loading | + +### Performance Features (10 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | Connection pooling | ✅ | OkHttpClient handles this | +| 2 | gRPC for data plane | ✅ | VectorServiceGrpc | +| 3 | Response metadata tracking | ✅ | ResponseMetadataListener | +| 4 | Concurrent operations | ✅ | AsyncIndex | +| 5 | Parallel batch processing | ⚠️ | Manual; no built-in utilities | +| 6 | Keep-alive configuration | ⚠️ | Via custom ManagedChannel | +| 7 | Client-side batching utilities | ❌ | Not available | +| 8 | Query result caching | ❌ | Not available | +| 9 | Connection reuse optimization | ❌ | Beyond OkHttpClient defaults | +| 10 | Streaming large results | ❌ | Not available | + +### Developer Experience (14 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | Builder pattern | ✅ | Pinecone.Builder() | +| 2 | Comprehensive documentation | ✅ | Extensive JavaDoc | +| 3 | Type safety | ✅ | Strong typing | +| 4 | Example code | ✅ | In JavaDoc and examples/ | +| 5 | Package manager distribution | ✅ | Maven Central | +| 6 | Standalone distribution | ✅ | Uberjar available | +| 7 | IDE friendly | ✅ | Clear method signatures | +| 8 | Integration tests | ✅ | src/integration/ | +| 9 | Error messages with links | ✅ | References to docs | +| 10 | Observability example | ✅ | OpenTelemetry example | +| 11 | Logging | ⚠️ | PINECONE_DEBUG only; no structured logging | +| 12 | Migration guides | ⚠️ | Exist but minimal | +| 13 | SDK initialization helpers | ❌ | No credential validation helper | +| 14 | Testing utilities | ❌ | No mock client | + +### Input Validation (13 items) + +| # | Feature | Status | Notes | +|---|---------|--------|-------| +| 1 | API key validation | ✅ | In build() | +| 2 | Index name validation | ✅ | Null/empty check | +| 3 | Dimension validation | ✅ | > 0 check | +| 4 | Metric validation | ✅ | Basic validation | +| 5 | Vector length validation | ✅ | gRPC proto validation | +| 6 | Namespace validation | ✅ | Null checks | +| 7 | Replica count validation | ✅ | >= 1 for pods | +| 8 | Shard count validation | ✅ | >= 1 for pods | +| 9 | Pod count validation | ✅ | replicas * shards = pods | +| 10 | Proxy configuration validation | ✅ | ProxyConfig.validate() | +| 11 | Collection name validation | ⚠️ | Basic; no format check | +| 12 | Backup name validation | ⚠️ | Minimal | +| 13 | Pre-flight dimension validation | ❌ | Not available | + +--- + +**Report Generated**: 2025-01-16 +**SDK Version Evaluated**: pinecone-client 6.0.0 +**Evaluator**: Cursor AI Agent +**Methodology**: Code review of /workspace Java SDK repository against generic SDK feature checklist