Issues in original projects

[madsmtm]

My work on fixing upstream issues, or at least opening new issues in this repo to track them.

objc issues:

• mem::swap doesn't work with Objects SSheldon/rust-objc#6
  • Tracked in Unstable: extern type support #73
• Adding a method isn't ergonomic SSheldon/rust-objc#12
  • Tracked in Better class declaration #30
• Implement Encode for more types SSheldon/rust-objc#26
  • The system has been improved in Add RefEncode, and make Encode bounds required #14, pointers to pointers now work.
  • And the rest is fixed by More Encode and RefEncode implementations #52.
• Should Object and other runtime types be Send/Sync? SSheldon/rust-objc#44
  • In Add objc_sys crate #19 we ensure that the types are not Send, Sync and Unpin by default
  • And then they were made the correct thing in Send and Sync fixes #94.
• Sending messages is inefficient because of selector lookup SSheldon/rust-objc#49
  • Tracked in Add static selectors #104
• Consider making objc no_std compatible SSheldon/rust-objc#51
  • Worked on in More no_std support #6, Prepare for a time when we can make the crates no_std #152 and Remove libstd from objc-sys and block-sys #305.
  • Remaining is mostly C types from std::os::raw, CStr and CString - see tracking issues Tracking Issue for core_ffi_c rust-lang/rust#94501 and Tracking Issue for feature(core_c_str) and feature(alloc_c_string) rust-lang/rust#98314.
  • Unsure about stuff in rc::autorelease?
  • Conclusion: This will happen at some point, but it requires higher MSRV and more compiler support.
• Add custom derive for Encode SSheldon/rust-objc#52
  • Tracked in derive macros #55
• API for passing already nul-terminated strings to avoid allocation SSheldon/rust-objc#54
  • Tracked in Add a terminated dependency and use NulTerminatedStr for inputs #113
• Type register and method export attributes for objc in Rust like C# in xamarin? SSheldon/rust-objc#56
  • The extern_class! and extern_methods! macros basically do this
• Unsound drop of uninitialised variable in Object::set_ivar. SSheldon/rust-objc#61
  • Fixed by Add RefEncode, and make Encode bounds required #14
• sel! can no longer be specifically macro_used in versions 0.2.3+ SSheldon/rust-objc#69
  • Already fixed upstream in Make objc macros compatible with use macro! SSheldon/rust-objc#76
• More macros SSheldon/rust-objc#74
  • Probably pretty future, tracked in Better class declaration #30
• Implement Default for WeakPtr? SSheldon/rust-objc#77
  • Done in Id improvements #21
• Docs link is stale SSheldon/rust-objc#78
  • Fixed in Improve documentation #13.
• Plan for higher-level bindings? SSheldon/rust-objc#79
  • Mostly answered, rest is tracked in Improve objc2::foundation #67
• Memory leaks when passing Drop objects to msg_send! SSheldon/rust-objc#80
  • Fixed by Add RefEncode, and make Encode bounds required #14
• More ergonomic references SSheldon/rust-objc#95
  • Done in Id improvements #21
• The future of the Objective-C crate ecosystem SSheldon/rust-objc#101
  • The reason this repo exist
• Get Object from Class? SSheldon/rust-objc#106
  • Answered
• Strange conflict between NSProcessInfo and NSScreen, causing segmentation fault. SSheldon/rust-objc#107
  • Answered
• Is the underlying BOOL type a bool on Apple silicon SSheldon/rust-objc#110
  • Answered
• How to call @available? SSheldon/rust-objc#111
  • Moved to How do we handle availability? #266
• Soundness issue with msg_send! SSheldon/rust-objc#112
  • Fixed in Change how mutability in msg_send! is done #150.
• iOS ClassDecl panic - Should I do something before a ClassDecl? SSheldon/rust-objc#113
  • Answered and documented in Various small fixes #84
• How to import and use constants SSheldon/rust-objc#114
  • Answered
• How to link struct from framework? SSheldon/rust-objc#115
  • Answered
• How do you not cause memory leaks? SSheldon/rust-objc#117
  • Answered
• How to use callback functions? SSheldon/rust-objc#118
  • Answered
• Basic documentation code does not compile SSheldon/rust-objc#119
  • Fixed by making macros hygenic
• Issue with callback functions SSheldon/rust-objc#120
  • Answered
• Add separate macro for msg_send! that does not verify message types SSheldon/rust-objc#121
  • Answered

objc PRs:

• Use mbox instead of malloc_buf SSheldon/rust-objc#72
  • Opened upstream Questions kennytm/mbox#20 for some changes I'd like to see.
  • See also malloced, malloc-array.
  • See also Features that require libc #500.
  • Conclusion: It's put behind a feature to cut down on dependencies (mbox/malloc_buf require libc).
• Change docs link to docs.rs SSheldon/rust-objc#81
  • Fixed in Improve documentation #13.
• change from http to https SSheldon/rust-objc#88
  • Fixed in Improve documentation #13.
• Derive Debug and PartialEq on a few more types SSheldon/rust-objc#93
  • Fixed in Better follow API guidelines #102
• Run rustfmt and require it in CI SSheldon/rust-objc#96
  • Fixed in Run cargo fmt #2
• Redo reference counting SSheldon/rust-objc#98
  • Moved to Id improvements #21.
• Cleanup CI SSheldon/rust-objc#99
  • Fixed in Fix CI setup #5
• Faster msg_send! SSheldon/rust-objc#100
  • Moved to Statically find msgSend functions on apple devices #15.
• Stop dereferencing msg_send!'s first argument SSheldon/rust-objc#102
  • Replaced by Improve message sending #38
• Make autoreleasepool take the pool as a parameter SSheldon/rust-objc#103
  • Moved to Make autoreleasepool take the pool as a parameter #17.
• Add unstable_extern_types feature SSheldon/rust-objc#104
  • Moved to Unstable: extern type support #73
• Make Sel an opaque struct like Ivar, Method, Class, Protocol and Object SSheldon/rust-objc#105
  • I think I agree with @SSheldon here, this something we shouldn't do, Sel makes sense as a normal Copy type
• increase number of MessageArguments impl tuples SSheldon/rust-objc#116
  • Included in Webkit #355
• Add apple tvos support SSheldon/rust-objc#122

objc_foundation:

• Make "into" methods take self with type Id<Self> SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#1
  • Tracked in Id conversion traits #48 / Make Id #[fundamental] #50
• Guarantee that pointers to NSObjects can be encoded SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#2
  • Fixed in Add RefEncode, and make Encode bounds required #14.
• Relicense under dual MIT/Apache-2.0 SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#5
  • Tracked in Relicense under trio MIT/Apache-2.0/Zlib #23.
• Violating soundness requirements SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#10
  • Tracked in Fix ownership in objc2-foundation #29.
• Casting to Object SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#11
  • Answered
• License File SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#12
  • Fixed by moving into this repo (which has a license file).
• memory leak in INSstring.as_str() SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#15
  • Tracked in Safer NSString #24.
• Link against gnustep-base on Linux SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#6
  • Merged into Fix CI setup #5. block still doesn't work, that is tracked elsewhere.
• add license file SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#13
• Manually dereference Id SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#14
  • Replaced by Improve message sending #38
• Basic version of NSError SSheldon/rust-objc-foundation#16
  • Fixed in Add basic version of NSError #221, further improvements to error handling in Better error handling in msg_send! and msg_send_id! #276 and Support error return and out parameters in define_class! #283

objc_exception:

• Relicense under dual MIT/Apache-2.0 SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#2
  • Tracked in Relicense under trio MIT/Apache-2.0/Zlib #23.
• Fails to cross-compile for Apple Silicon SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#6
  • Fixed in Fix CI setup #5 (which included Don't include objc headers in exception.m SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#8)
• Add no_std support and migrate to 2018 edition SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#7
  • Fixed in Fix warnings, and other chores #3 and More no_std support #6.
• Don't include objc headers in exception.m SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#8
  • Included in Fix CI setup #5.
• Use a struct to represent Exception instead of an uninhabited enum SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#9
  • Moved to Use structs to represent objects instead of uninhabited enums #7.
• Make throw more efficient SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#10
  • Included in Fix CI setup #5.
• Use nightly features SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#11
  • Mostly for prosperity.
• Will not compile with homebrew's GCC. SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#12
  • I'm not sure if we can support GCC, or if their Objective-C support is too terrible?
  • Moved to Support better cross compilation, as well as other compilers (GCC) #499
• cross compile from x86_64 linux to aarch64-apple-darwin SSheldon/rust-objc-exception#13
  • Fixed in Fix CI setup #5

objc-encode:

• Improve documentation SSheldon/rust-objc-encode#2
  • Moved to Improve documentation #13.
• Implement Encode for arrays using const generics SSheldon/rust-objc-encode#3
  • Moved to Implement Encode for arrays using const generics #10.
• Change Encoding parameter sizes SSheldon/rust-objc-encode#4
  • Moved to Change Encoding parameter sizes #11.
• Support architectures with pointer width 16 SSheldon/rust-objc-encode#5
  • Moved to Support architectures with pointer width 16 #12.
• Use str::strip_prefix instead of custom rm_prefix function SSheldon/rust-objc-encode#6
  • Fixed in Fix warnings, and other chores #3.
• Implement Encode for unsized types as well SSheldon/rust-objc-encode#7
  • Moved to Implement Encode for unsized types as well #9.
• Implement a to_string method for Encoding enum SSheldon/rust-objc-encode#8
  • Answered

objc_id:

• Convert a slice of Ids to references at zero-cost SSheldon/rust-objc-id#1
  • Included in Id traits #41
• Allow Option<Id<T>> to use the null pointer optimization SSheldon/rust-objc-id#2
  • Done as part of Id improvements #21.
• Relicense under dual MIT/Apache-2.0 SSheldon/rust-objc-id#3
  • Tracked in Relicense under trio MIT/Apache-2.0/Zlib #23.
• Default Id to shared by renaming {Id => OwnedId} and {ShareId => Id} SSheldon/rust-objc-id#4
  • Id improvements #21 removed the default, then we can add a new one back later in a backwards-compatible way if we figure out that's desired!
• Consider setting an associated object to verify that owned Ids are unique SSheldon/rust-objc-id#5
  • Tracked in Verify that an Ids' ownership is correct using associated objects #127
• License File SSheldon/rust-objc-id#6
  • Fixed by moving into this repo (which has a license file).
• add MIT license file SSheldon/rust-objc-id#7
  • Fixed by moving into this repo (which has a license file).
• Fix Send and Sync implementations on Id and WeakId SSheldon/rust-objc-id#8
  • Moved to Fix Send and Sync implementations on Id and WeakId #8.

block

Moved to #168.

[madsmtm]

At this point I've either fixed the entirety of the list, or opened separate issues to track our progress on it.

I will continue to watch the original repositories, and submit issues to this repo where relevant.