[codex] Guardrail backlog: Other feedback (other-feedback)

[haasonsaas]

Other feedback

This issue tracks a recurring review-feedback class from the EvalOps review feedback sentinel.

• Class: other-feedback
• Score: 270
• Findings: 3
• Repos: evalops/hopper, evalops/maestro
• Generated at: 2026-05-14T12:59:25Z
• Window: merged since 2026-05-11 with minimum severity high

Guardrail to build

Review manually before converting this class into a repo-local guardrail.

Representative feedback

• p0 evalops/hopper#185 top-level feedback
  • https://github.com/evalops/hopper/pull/185#pullrequestreview-4288115524
• p1 evalops/hopper#183 top-level feedback
  • https://github.com/evalops/hopper/pull/183#pullrequestreview-4287562796
• p1 chore: sync public mirror from internal maestro#397 src/agent/providers/scripted.ts:522
  • Preserve retryability for transient scripted errors
  • chore: sync public mirror from internal maestro#397 (comment)

Finding fingerprints

• 50fe4fd97adbd47fff0563aa1daa301ed3ddcfd74f749023694df80999213a52
• 8cb3eb661afea8226c88c6971e24b0a830e5ba312d33ecafdc91016c761e502d
• d863568881da571352020fa12e5b2491bff788a9b926ce755f42ce9f8eb57a1e

Acceptance criteria

• The class has an owner repo and a concrete guardrail location.
• The guardrail fails for at least one representative feedback shape listed above.
• The guardrail is wired into the smallest relevant CI or preflight target.
• The issue is closed only after the guardrail has merged and the feedback sentinel no longer ranks this class as an unaddressed candidate.

[haasonsaas]

Closing because the review feedback sentinel no longer ranks other-feedback as an active guardrail candidate in the current backlog window.

[haasonsaas]

Closing because the review feedback sentinel no longer ranks other-feedback as an active guardrail candidate in the current backlog window.