diff --git a/EssentialsDiscord/src/main/java/net/essentialsx/discord/DiscordSettings.java b/EssentialsDiscord/src/main/java/net/essentialsx/discord/DiscordSettings.java
index f2526a08cd..19e369f410 100644
--- a/EssentialsDiscord/src/main/java/net/essentialsx/discord/DiscordSettings.java
+++ b/EssentialsDiscord/src/main/java/net/essentialsx/discord/DiscordSettings.java
@@ -600,7 +600,7 @@ public void reloadConfig() {
                 "username", "displayname", "controllername", "controllerdisplayname", "reason");
         kickFormat = generateMessageFormat(getFormatString("kick"), "{displayname} was kicked with reason: {reason}", false,
                 "username", "displayname", "reason");
-        pmToDiscordFormat = generateMessageFormat(getFormatString("private-chat"), "[SocialSpy] {sender-username} -> {receiver-username}: {message}", false,
+        pmToDiscordFormat = generateMessageFormat(getFormatString("pms-to-discord"), "[SocialSpy] {sender-username} -> {receiver-username}: {message}", false,
                 "sender-username", "sender-displayname", "receiver-username", "receiver-displayname", "message");
 
         plugin.onReload();